Big Brother Gossip Search
Recent Posts
CBS All Access- Try 1 month free w/code: 1MFREE
CBS All Access- Try 1 month free w/code: 1MFREE
Get The Live Feeds
CBS All Access- Try 1 month free w/code: 1MFREE
Big Brother Gossip Show

I now have a website set up where you can go to hear current and old episodes of the Big Brother Gossip podcast.  Please go to!


The Season's Authors

Click for their posts.




Target John

Twitter Feeds

Syndication Links
« Guide to the #BB15 Season Finale | Main | The Night Owl »

Conspiracies, theories, facts, fiction.....

Here is a LONG post I've been adding to over the last several weeks.  First some things about this season of Big Brother and then more general information about the ways production can influence the HGs or the game.

I started this a right before Amanda’s eviction so take that into account (yes it took me ages to write this).

Show connections, casting, recruiting:

Amanda is not 'friends' with Alison Grodner (BB Executive Producer) and was not 'recruited' to be on Big Brother.  I heard (via the twitter grapevine) that during the baseball HoH competition Amanda said she knew one of the 'production' people that was throwing the balls at them. Amanda DID previously work in LA so its possible she saw someone she knew from her past life when she was trying to become a star.  Amanda was not 'pre-destined' to win Big Brother 15 (As we saw she was evicted and not because the 'secret' plot was posted on facebook 2 months ago).

On the other hand, Elissa IS at the very least acquainted with Alison Grodner and was recruited to be on Big Brother by CBS.

With the exception of Kaitlin who said she was approached to apply while bartending - the other HGs seemed to have all applied.  Aaryn's agency may have applied on her behalf or encouraged her to apply but you get my point, the only members that were 'cast' for this season were Elissa and Kaitlin and they were two very different situations. Helen also was not 'cast' but that goes in a different conspiracy (mini update - someone tells me Candice has said she was sort of recruited - so toss her into the mix as well).

Helen was not a CBS plant and did NOT 'throw' the HoH competition where she fell off the platform. Why she would quit the game right when she had a chance to get back in is beyond reason to me. How much could CBS have paid her to give up a shot at $500k? And I come to that conclusion without even watching the "live" video (and not the 5 second copy floating around) - its very obvious she simply lost her balance and jumped off. GO back – watch the last 2-3 minutes before she fell – you could see how she was struggling.  No pushing or 'tapping.'  Candice also lost her balance and fell off just a few moments later.

Money: Yes the HGs are PAID for their time on Big Brother.  The Hgs last season and this season have implied they now get about $1,000 a week while in sequester, the BB house, and Jury House (the number $13,000 has been tossed around a lot by the HGs when talking - BB is about 13 weeks).  In the previous seasons the number was always said to be about $750 per week. Alumni are believed to GET MORE. I think the 'coaches' last season had separate contracts with as the very least a guaranteed minimum they would get to come back on the show.  I also believe Elissa is being paid much more than the other HGs this season because of her connection with her sister Rachel.

Who’s actually been fired?

As of this writing, 9/16/2013, the only two CONFIRMED people that have lost their jobs are Aaryn and GinaMarie.  Keep in mind that Aaryn was simply dropped by her agency – she considers herself a college student.  GinaMarie’s job couldn’t have been that much of a full time gig since she was able to take off the entire summer.    Actually EVERY house guest this season was not fully employed (Spencer being the one exception) – they all were part timers or between jobs.

Rumored job losses are just that – false rumors.   

Spencer has not lost his job, he took a leave of absence before starting Big Brother – I believe he is off until the beginning or end of October – they can’t ‘fire’ him – I don’t think he will lose his job no matter what but nothing will happen either way until he is back on the job.   He is a union member and you can be sure that they will work their tails off to keep him from losing his job and that is if the company even feels it has a reason to fire him (again, I don’t think he is in any danger of losing his job).

Andy is listed on the show as a “College Professor” but that is a HUGE stretch (one made by CBS in my opinion and not Andy). In reality Andy has done stints with a SMALL college in the Chicago area (a two-year community college) as a “Part Time” instructor.  Folks that means he may have his Masters degree at best and they paid him to teach one or two classes a semester.   He said in the house that he couldn’t go back to that job if he was still in the house after a certain point.  The college put out a statement saying he is not employed by them BECAUSE HE ISN’T – not because he was ‘fired.’  Huge difference.

Amanda’s name has also been tossed out as having lost her job.  Amanda’s most recent occupation before Big Brother was / is as a Realtor.  Having done this type of work for a couple of years myself I can tell you that it’s not a job you can be fired from.  You are your OWN boss.  At best you work for a broker but you are paid on commission only and if a broker were to drop you, you could just walk down the street to another broker and sign up with them.

These are all rumors stirred up by people looking to generate traffic to their websites.  Go to trusted sources only for your info.

And now some more general Big Brother stuff about competitions and such…


Certain competitions favor certain Hgs:

Production CAN, to some extent, control the 'game' if they choose to (I'm not saying they always do - but sometimes we sure wonder).  CBS does EXTENSIVE 'testing' of applicants - they know each one's strengths and weaknesses. 

Hanging competitions WILL favor lighter & smaller framed Hgs (same goes on Survivor - see who lasts the longest when they hang over water - 90% of the time its the small women). Yes McCrae won the first competition that involved hanging but he also said later he has the body of a woman (yes he said that).

If a certain Hgs is good at memorizing, then perhaps production would choose a important week for that HG to give the house a competition involving memorization. Example? BB14 Ian claimed to have a photographic memory and won a critical competition near the end of his season that required a good memory (As a side note BB15 Jeremy said he had a "photoshop" memory - poor guy).

Ask Brendon about competitions that favor people with SMALL feet (standing on a ledge?).  Balance can also play a huge factor. I said it on the night of the baseball competition this season that Elissa had a HUGE advantage with her yoga background as she was able to grab balls and maintain her balance while others struggled to do both.

Comps that involve cold/wet conditions may favor HGs with more 'body fat' because they won't lose their body temperature as quickly.

Drugs? Its hard to argue about the talk in the house this season of certain HGs being on ADD meds or Xanax and that it might help or hurt them in competitions depending on when they were given. Some HGs feel that certain comps were slated to take place when these HGs were at their 'best' from the meds they happen to be on (Aaryn, Amanda and Judd all are taking medications - others might be as well). I for one doubt it gave any 'advantage' but at best evened the playing field.

Production giving certain ‘lanes’ an advantage?  In theory the way the Hgs line up for competitions is done by a ‘random’ draw – but we never see the draw so we can only guess how that works (if any former HG wants to chime in and tell me they think its always legit – please do!).  What we do know is there have been several times in the recent years where things have seemed to be set up to ‘help’ a favorite to win that POV or HoH when it was needed.  Two quick examples would be:

1: The ‘clown shoe’ competition (BB13) that Jeff lost because he accidently tossed out a clown shoe that was seemed  very close to the top of the ‘bouncy balls’ he had to dig though.  Had he seen it he would have beaten Porsche by a huge margin and would have stayed in the game (so this is viewed by many as a attempt to influence the game that failed).

2: The reward/penalty POV competition this season where Elissa got the most points and won the POV when she needed it most.  After the competition the HGs commented on how all the high numbers were on one side of the ‘mud pit’ – the side that Elissa was on.  As a matter of facet the top three places were from one side of the mud pit.  Once has to wonder how Elissa, who would most likely have been voted out had she not won, was selected for that lane – or were the numbers places in the pit AFTER lane selection?


Power of Veto Selection:

The Power of Veto was introduced in BB3.  It has gone through several changes.  It was introduced as a way to give the nominations a chance to be changed up.  Originally everyone played – then the number was limited. In Big Brother 5, Nakomis came up with the plan to “backdoor” Jase by not nominating him and NOT letting him play for the POV.  This eventually led to the addition of the “Wheel” to select players which only lasted 2 episodes during Big Brother 7.  They then moved to the ‘bag’ that names were drawn from.    This bag has raised all kinds of questions and theories.  Most of the time the HGs are NOT allowed to dump out the bag after selecting names to verify all names are there (yes they did dump it out at least once last season).   We just have no way to know for sure that the current name selection process to play for POV is legit.


Coup d’Etat, Pandora’s Box:

Because there is no rhyme or reason to when the things happen, most hard core fans agree the Coup d'Etat & Pandora's Box are only vehicles used by production to help certain players (or just for entertainment value when no special powers are awarded with Pandora). 

The  Coup d’etat, where the holder gets to whipe out current nominations and make his/her own at a moment’s notice, has only been awarded twice – the first time Mike Boogey won it and didn’t use it (since his alliance was in power those two weeks) – the second time Jeff won it and used it to save himself (we felt it was used that season for this very reason - to keep Jeff in the game). 

Pandora’s box is often just sillyness – but since there is no set rules on what the award / penalty is – or if it’s just a ‘for fun’ thing – production can announce it ahead of time and change how it is presented depending on who is the HoH at the time – thus having the chance to majorly influence the game. 


Diary Room ‘Influence’

Every season we hear the Hgs talk about the “DR” wanting things – or not wanting things.  I’ve always felt that the Diary Room is where production can work on the HGs mindsets and, by asking certain questions, get them to think in certain ways.  They can also brow beat a houseguest into thinking about nominating or not nominating someone by presenting may many alternative options while asking those leading questions.   I’ve talked about this one enough in previous seasons and actually this year I didn’t feel it happened as much – except perhaps when we thought Howard was going to get nominated by MVP Elissa and instead she put up Spencer.  Helen, Elissa and others all felt like the DR was pushing very hard to NOT have Howard go up that week (and he didn’t).

And there you have it.  A HUGE post about loads of rumors, gossip, speculation and a few facts tossed in for fun.  I may or may not post again this season but in case I don’t – thanks for sticking with us or finding us this year.  Assuming there is a Big Brother 16 we will be back reporting all over again.  And yes we will probably have some ‘favorites’ but in the end I probably won’t care who wins – just like I don’t care who wins this season.

-Mike aka ‘indy mike’ aka @bbgossip

Reader Comments (12)

You're a brave, brave man.
September 16, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterScott
Well said. Agree 100% on this!
September 16, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterBig Brother Rat
Scott - too many words for most to work their way through - although someone said Amanda said on the feeds she knows Grodner - I am waiting for the flashback time so can post it. If she DID say it (I'll believe it when I hear it) I think the context will explain it away.

Rat - ty very much!
September 16, 2013 | Unregistered Commenterindymike
@Mike....what an excellent job of explaining how production fine tunes BB. I really enjoyed it. There's nothing like it anywhere. This is the type of information that fans like myself are looking for, not all the inconsequencial character assignations you usually find.
September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterNancy
Productions hand in comps was never more apparent than when they handed Miss Roller Derby Queen part 1 of the last comp.
September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterNancy
Mike many thanks for all the info. Appreciate all the time it took to compile it. During BB season we tend to hear all kinds of crap. It can be difficult to separate fact from fiction and thanks to you I now "get it". Looking forward to your informative opining next year. You are the best !!
September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterAlohaCher
Mike - great stuff!!! Thank you very much for the unbiased, factual & very thoughtful post. Many of us would love to be able to have a venue like you do to get these very points across. Thanks to you guys, we don't have to! :)

The one additional comment I would add is DR's potential influence over Elissa's game. Two of her whackier-than-usual plans were launched immediately after exiting DR.

Exhibit A - the plan to try to save Aaryn and renom (not backdoor as you so aptly pointed out) Amanda was set in motion as she exited DR the Friday night before Veto. It was the night they drew players on Friday and Zingbot woke them Saturday.

Exhibit B - the plan to work with Amanda, McCrae & Andy to keep Amanda instead of Spencer was kicked off within seconds of walking out of Diary. Flashback 9/3, 12:32:35AM - Elissa walks out of DR asking if GinaMarie is down stairs. A few minutes later, 12:39:02 - Elissa is standing at the kitchen sink and mouths (presumably to Amanda) and points to the cockpit "go in there." The discussion that follows is the plan to vote to keep Amanda and making a F3 deal with her & McCrae.
These very well may have been Elissa's plans and it was just a coincidence that her two most out-of-character moves were made immediately after leaving DR, but... Well, you can decide for yourself. :)

Thanks again for a great season!
September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterHeather
@Heather....I'm you have some kind of photographic memory? Talk about'd make a good FBI agent...wouldn't get anything over on you.
September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterNancy
Even if this stuff hadn't been lunchtime conversation for months, I would have enjoyed seeing it written down in one place. As a newbie, I guess I can't really say "Oh, you're so right" or "You're full of crap" since for all I know you, Ash, and Scott are all part of the grand conspiracy to script out everything that happened and will still happen during #BB15.

But there's just one thing I have to call you on here ... and it's the bullish!t that Helen, my favorite player, wasn't pushed. Didn't you see the screen cap which was all over the interwebs the night of the juror competition which clearly showed a hand sticking way out from the wall pushing Helen off the platform? Conspiracy proof positive! It's fixed, I tells ya!

September 17, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterTarget John
Interesting post..just one more thing to add....Candice said she was recruited too...apparently she met a producer from the show like two years ago and they called her up two weeks before the season started....could be she was a last minute replacement for someone that didn't work out..who knows...anyway, Aaryn and GM were always talking about it during one of their many Candice bashing sessions, how "ungrateful" she was to be there because she was recruited two weeks before the show and a real fan should have had her spot, blah blah blah...just thought I'd add...
September 18, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterRandom
Thank you all for your thoughts and comments!

Random - I missed that but am not surprised - there usually are one or two 'last minute' replacements. After 15 seasons I just know and accept it so sometimes its hard for me to come up with specific facts to convince the newer folks.

Heather - I have absolutley no doubt in my mind that production helped Elissa play the game (for better or worse), I just felt like I'd already singled her out a couple times in my posts and the "DR" influence is one horse I've beaten to death over the last 7 seasons (I recall thinking about it in BB8 as the first season I really took notice of it).
September 18, 2013 | Unregistered Commenterindymike
What a great blog! I wish I had had this a few seasons back when everyone was so sure there was no way for production to influence the game. You covered every point so thoroughly. Imagine CBS getting stuck with a dud they couldn't influence to make more exciting? I have always thought they very carefully craft and schedule comps around HGs talents and skills, ever since Maggie said she bowled often and was very good, the week she needed to win, and she did. It used to upset me, but now I'm more philosophical....I love an exciting show! Thanks for a great comprehensive story about this subject, and a great website and podcast.
September 21, 2013 | Unregistered Commentercyninbend

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.